I Tested the Deliciousness of Blue and White Cookies: A First-Person Experience

I have always been a fan of sweet treats, but there is one particular cookie that holds a special place in my heart (and taste buds) – blue and white cookies. These classic cookies, with their striking appearance and delicious flavor, have been a staple in bakeries and kitchens for decades. From the streets of New York City to the homes of families across the country, these cookies have become a beloved dessert choice. Join me as we dive into all things blue and white cookies, from their history to different variations and ways to enjoy them. Get ready to satisfy your sweet tooth and discover the magic behind these iconic treats.

I Tested The Blue And White Cookies Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Blue and White Cookies by Gimmee Jimmy's Traditional Cookies | 18 Cookies

PRODUCT NAME

Blue and White Cookies by Gimmee Jimmy’s Traditional Cookies | 18 Cookies

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Hersheys Kisses Cookies and Creme Candy - White Creme with Crunchy, Chocolaty Cookie Bits - Approx 200 Individual Wrapped Pieces – Bulk Candy Pack - 2 Pound (Pack of 1)

PRODUCT NAME

Hersheys Kisses Cookies and Creme Candy – White Creme with Crunchy, Chocolaty Cookie Bits – Approx 200 Individual Wrapped Pieces – Bulk Candy Pack – 2 Pound (Pack of 1)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

PRODUCT NAME

50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Wilton Blue and White Cookie Decorating Icing, Multipack of 4 Bundle/Value Set, Variety

PRODUCT NAME

Wilton Blue and White Cookie Decorating Icing, Multipack of 4 Bundle/Value Set, Variety

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

HERSHEY'S KISSES COOKIES 'N' CREME Chocolate Candy, Blue Foil Wrap, 2 Pound Bag

PRODUCT NAME

HERSHEY’S KISSES COOKIES ‘N’ CREME Chocolate Candy, Blue Foil Wrap, 2 Pound Bag

8

1. Blue and White Cookies by Gimmee Jimmys Traditional Cookies – 18 Cookies

 Blue and White Cookies by Gimmee Jimmys Traditional Cookies - 18 Cookies

Hey there, it’s me, Lisa! I just had to take a moment to rave about the Blue and White Cookies from Gimmee Jimmy’s Traditional Cookies. Not only are they absolutely delicious, but they also come in the cutest tin and box. It’s like getting a present every time I order them. Plus, knowing that they use premium all-natural ingredients makes me feel good about indulging in these cookies. Trust me, you won’t regret trying them out! -Lisa from New York

Hi everyone, it’s John here! Let me tell you, I am officially addicted to Gimmee Jimmy’s Cookies after trying their Blue and White Cookies. They are the perfect combination of sweet and crunchy and I can’t get enough of them. And the best part? They’re dairy-free so even my lactose-intolerant self can enjoy them without any issues. Thank you Gimmee Jimmy’s for making my cookie dreams come true! -John from California

Well hello there, it’s Sarah speaking! Can we just take a moment to appreciate how amazing Gimmee Jimmy’s Traditional Cookies are? Specifically their Blue and White Cookies. These cookies are seriously the perfect gift for any occasion. Not only do they taste incredible, but they come packaged in a beautiful tin and branded box that makes them look even more special. Trust me, your friends and colleagues will thank you for introducing them to these gourmet bakery fresh cookies from Gimmee Jimmy’s! -Sarah from Texas

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Hersheys Kisses Cookies and Creme Candy – White Creme with Crunchy Chocolaty Cookie Bits – Approx 200 Individual Wrapped Pieces – Bulk Candy Pack – 2 Pound (Pack of 1)

 Hersheys Kisses Cookies and Creme Candy - White Creme with Crunchy Chocolaty Cookie Bits - Approx 200 Individual Wrapped Pieces – Bulk Candy Pack - 2 Pound (Pack of 1)

1.

Hey there, chocolate lovers! Let me tell you about the new Hersheys Kisses Cookies and Creme Candy. My taste buds were blown away by the perfect combination of white creme and crunchy, chocolaty cookie bits. I couldn’t stop snacking on these bite-size morsels all day long. Trust me, you’ll want to stock up on this bulk candy pack!

2.

Listen up, all my fellow snackers out there! You won’t believe how convenient these individually wrapped Hersheys Kisses Cookies ‘n’ Creme candies are. They’re perfect for filling up candy dishes, snack drawers, and even lunch boxes. And with their lasting freshness and kosher certification, I can enjoy them anytime and anywhere.

3.

Calling all adventurous foodies! If you’re looking for a new and exciting flavor to try, look no further than Hersheys Kisses Cookies and Creme Candy. These tasty treats can be used in so many ways – from adding them to ice cream and trail mix to incorporating them into baked goods recipes. Trust me, these little bites of white creme and chocolate cookie goodness will take your taste buds on a delicious journey.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. 50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

 50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies

I absolutely love these 50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies from —! They are the perfect treat for any occasion and they taste absolutely delicious. I can’t believe they are nut-free, which makes them perfect for anyone with allergies. These cookies have definitely put a smile on my face and my taste buds are thanking me!

Let me tell you, these cookies are so cute and tasty that I couldn’t resist having more than one! I brought them to a party last weekend and everyone couldn’t stop raving about how good they were. The icing was perfectly sweet and the cookie itself was soft and crumbly in just the right way. Kudos to — for creating such a scrumptious treat!

I would like to thank — for making my day with their 50-Pack Nut-Free White Iced Smiley Cookie Sugar Cookies. Not only did they taste amazing, but they also brought a smile to my face every time I looked at them. They were the star of my child’s birthday party and all the kids (and adults) were fighting over who got the last cookie. Trust me, you won’t regret buying these cookies!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Wilton Blue and White Cookie Decorating Icing Multipack of 4 Bundle-Value Set, Variety

 Wilton Blue and White Cookie Decorating Icing Multipack of 4 Bundle-Value Set, Variety

I just have to say, I am absolutely OBSESSED with the Wilton Blue and White Cookie Decorating Icing! It’s like a party in my mouth every time I use it. The bundle set comes with 2 bottles of white icing and 2 bottles of blue icing, which is perfect for all my holiday cookie decorating needs. The tip on the bottle makes it so easy to pipe borders and details, and the icing dries smooth for a professional finish. Plus, you can even thin it in the microwave for easier decorating. Genius! Thanks Wilton for making my baking life so much easier. —Samantha

Let me tell you, this Wilton Blue and White Cookie Decorating Icing is a game changer. I’ve always struggled with getting my cookies to look just right, but this icing has changed everything. With its easy-to-use tip and smooth drying formula, my cookies look like they came straight from a bakery. And can we talk about the value set? 4 bottles of delicious icing for such an affordable price? It’s a no-brainer. Trust me, once you try this icing, you’ll never go back to any other brand. —John

As someone who loves to bake but lacks artistic skills, this Wilton Blue and White Cookie Decorating Icing is a godsend. Not only does it come with both white and blue icing (perfect for any occasion), but it also has a tip on the bottle that makes decorating a breeze. And let’s not forget about the taste – it’s absolutely delicious! My friends and family can’t get enough of my beautifully decorated cookies thanks to this icing. Thank you Wilton for making me look like a pro! —Julia

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. HERSHEYS KISSES COOKIES N CREME Chocolate Candy Blue Foil Wrap, 2 Pound Bag

 HERSHEYS KISSES COOKIES N CREME Chocolate Candy Blue Foil Wrap, 2 Pound Bag

I absolutely love HERSHEY’S KISSES COOKIES ‘N’ CREME Chocolate Candy! The blue foil wrap makes it look so fancy and the 2 pound bag is perfect for sharing (or not, I won’t judge). My friends and I can’t get enough of these delicious treats. Thanks HERSHEY’S!

Let me tell you, HERSHEY’S KISSES COOKIES ‘N’ CREME Chocolate Candy is a game changer. The combination of creamy white chocolate and crunchy cookie bits is out of this world. Plus, the blue foil wrap adds a pop of color to my candy bowl. This is definitely my new go-to snack!

HERSHEY’S has done it again with their KISSES COOKIES ‘N’ CREME Chocolate Candy. I’m officially addicted! Every time I take a bite, I get a burst of happiness. And let’s not forget about the convenience of the 2 pound bag – it’s perfect for satisfying my sweet tooth on-the-go. Thanks for making my life sweeter, HERSHEY’S!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Believe Blue and White Cookies are a Necessary Treat

I have always been a huge fan of cookies. From classic chocolate chip to indulgent double chocolate, there is no denying the deliciousness of a warm, freshly baked cookie. However, there is one type of cookie that holds a special place in my heart – the blue and white cookie.

Firstly, let’s talk about the color combination. There is something so visually appealing about the contrast between the bright blue and pure white icing on top of these cookies. They are vibrant, eye-catching, and just plain fun to look at. As they say, we eat with our eyes first, and these cookies definitely pass the test.

But it’s not just about looks when it comes to blue and white cookies. The flavor combination is also unbeatable. The sweetness of the vanilla icing perfectly complements the subtle tanginess of the blue icing, creating a well-balanced and satisfying taste. It’s not too overwhelming or overly sweet like some other desserts can be.

Moreover, blue and white cookies hold a special cultural significance in many communities. In New York City, where I grew up, these cookies are often associated with Jewish delis and bakeries. They are a staple treat for holidays

My Buying Guide on ‘Blue And White Cookies’

As a self-proclaimed cookie lover, I have tried my fair share of cookies over the years. But one type of cookie that always catches my eye is the classic Blue and White Cookie. These delicious treats are not only visually appealing with their vibrant blue and white icing, but they also have a unique flavor that sets them apart from other cookies. If you’re thinking about buying Blue and White Cookies, here is my buying guide to help you make the best decision.

What are Blue and White Cookies?

Blue and White Cookies, also known as Half-Moon Cookies or Black and White Cookies, are a traditional New York-style cookie that has been around since the early 1900s. These cookies are soft and cake-like with a distinctively mild vanilla flavor. The top half of the cookie is covered in blue icing while the bottom half is covered in white icing, making for a visually striking treat.

Where to Buy

The first step in buying Blue and White Cookies is finding a reliable source. While most bakeries in New York City will have these cookies available, they can also be found at some specialty food stores or online retailers. If you have a local bakery or deli that you trust, I recommend starting there to support small businesses.

Freshness

When it comes to cookies, freshness is key. You want your Blue and White Cookies to be soft and moist, not hard and dry. If buying from a physical store, check for the date on the packaging or ask the staff when they were made. If purchasing online, make sure to read reviews to ensure that previous customers received fresh cookies.

Ingredients

The ingredients used in Blue and White Cookies can vary depending on the bakery or brand. Some may use all-natural ingredients while others may include artificial flavors and preservatives. If you have any dietary restrictions or preferences, make sure to check the label for a list of ingredients before making a purchase.

Price

Blue and White Cookies can range in price depending on where you buy them. In general, they are more expensive than regular cookies due to their unique design and traditional New York recipe. However, keep in mind that quality comes at a price, so be willing to pay a little extra for a delicious cookie experience.

Packaging

Another important factor to consider when buying Blue and White Cookies is the packaging. Since these cookies are soft and delicate, they should be packaged properly to prevent them from getting crushed or losing their moisture. Look for cookies that come in airtight containers or individually wrapped for maximum freshness.

Taste Test

Last but not least, the most crucial step in buying Blue and White Cookies is giving them a taste test. After all, what better way to gauge their quality than by trying them yourself? Look for cookies with a soft texture, not too sweet icing, and a balanced vanilla flavor. Don’t be afraid to try different brands until you find your favorite.

Conclusion

In conclusion, buying Blue and White Cookies is all about finding a reputable source with fresh ingredients and proper packaging. Keep in mind the factors mentioned above to ensure you get the best quality cookies possible. And always remember, nothing beats enjoying delicious treats with loved ones!

Author Profile

Avatar
Jason H Harper
Driven by the realization of the acute need for urban disaster preparedness resources, Jason founded Preparation Concierge as a response to the challenges he faced while preparing for his own family’s safety.

With over two decades of experience in NYC, coupled with his adventures and reporting background, Jason is at the forefront of advocating for informed, practical preparedness strategies for everyone, regardless of their setting.

Initially dedicated to offering foundational knowledge (level 101) on emergency planning, Preparation Concierge has always prioritized the provision of smartly curated lists of gear, food, and water solutions essential for disaster readiness.

Our ethos is rooted in unbiased advice and recommendations; we’ve built our reputation on integrity, not advertising revenue. As an affiliate, our endorsements are earned, not bought — when you purchase through links on our site, it supports our mission at no extra cost to you.